Insomnia (insomnia) wrote,

Creativity vs. Usability... the URRRGH factor.

You know... every few months, I see a really good article on web site design/usability that just completely contradicts with my creative side. An argument ensues inside me, my personality is ripped in two, and the paradox dissolves my sanity until I am left naked, helpless, in a fetal position, crying on my bathroom floor. (well, not really, but you get the idea...)

Mr. Usability:
You really should design a site that serves a purpose... What is the point (or the need) for just another ego-oriented website... another fashion plate? You should be out building online communities that matter. Just take a look at the article that Phillip Greenspun wrote on purposeful communities... don't you want a popular site that actually brings people together? If you're going to do a site like that, you really should forget about Flash animation, too... it's just what it says it is... Flash. It doesn't improve usability, it wastes bandwidth without conveying information more effectively, and it doesn't even work on every browser. Do you really think that you know more about web design than Jakob Nielsen? I mean, the guy charges $30K a day just to review websites and improve usability."

Mr. Creativity:
"Screw usability. I like sights that aren't always instinctive... that are unpredictable... that are beautiful and creative. There is very little on the web that is more beautiful and moving than entropy8zuper, but the interface there is far from instinctual... you have to search for it. You have to be creative... you have to explore the beauty and emotions, which unfold like a flower.
What do you want to live for anyway? Art or a faster, text-based website?!!"

Someone pass me a box of Kleenex and a blanket. I'm going to be crying for awhile and the tile on the bathroom floor gets so cold at night...

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.